What Are Philadelphia's Forgotten Foods?

Let's take a stroll down memory lane and unearth some of Philadelphia's most intriguing lost flavors.

Savory & Main Dishes: A Hearty Past

Philadelphia's early diet was robust, reflecting the city's status as a significant port and agricultural hub.

• Snapper Soup: Once a ubiquitous fixture in Philadelphia's finest restaurants and homes, this rich, dark soup made from snapping turtle meat was a local delicacy. Often spiced with sherry and intensely flavorful, it was a celebratory dish that has largely vanished from menus today.
• Fried Oysters with Chicken Salad: This seemingly unusual pairing was a bona fide classic. During the 19th and early 20th centuries, fried oysters were commonly served alongside chicken salad and a zesty pepper hash. It was a testament to the abundance of fresh oysters from the Delaware Bay.
• Fried Catfish on Waffles: Imagine this unexpected combination! In the 19th century, catfish were plentiful in the Schuylkill River. It was a common and inexpensive protein, often enjoyed alongside hot, crispy waffles – a surprising sweet and savory duo that deserves a modern revival.
• Pepper Pot Soup: This spicy, tripe-based soup was a true working-class staple, famously said to have sustained the Continental Army during the brutal winter at Valley Forge. It's a testament to frugality and flavor.
• Mock Turtle Soup: A more accessible alternative to the exotic snapper soup, mock turtle soup was made with less expensive ingredients like calf's head and feet. It aimed to replicate the rich texture and flavor without the rare main ingredient.

Sweets & Snacks: A Hint of Whimsy

Philadelphia's sweet tooth was just as adventurous.

• Teaberry Ice Cream: A vibrant pink ice cream with a distinctive wintergreen-like flavor, it is made from the native teaberry shrub. Its unique, earthy, and refreshing taste was once a regional favorite, though now it's a rare find.
• Wilbur Buds: Before Hershey's Kiss conquered the nation, Wilbur Buds were the original "chocolate drops" made by the Wilbur Chocolate Company in Philadelphia. These flattened, tear-shaped chocolates were incredibly popular and set the stage for small, individual chocolate treats.
• Fried Apple Pie: Not your typical slice! These were small, crescent-shaped pastries, generously filled with apples and deep-fried to a golden crisp. A perfect handheld treat.
• Cara-Mellows: Simple yet delightful, these were essentially marshmallows dipped in rich, gooey caramel, offering a textural contrast that was a popular confection.
• Raspberry Shrub: A non-alcoholic, refreshing drink made from a fruit and vinegar concentrate, then mixed with water or seltzer. Shrubs were popular before refrigeration, offering a tangy, sweet way to preserve fruit flavors.

Enduring & Abundant Classics

While some foods are truly forgotten, others, like these, have seen their prominence diminish but still hold a place in Philly's heart:

• Scrapple: Though not "forgotten," scrapple's intense regionality makes it noteworthy. This German-influenced dish of ground pork scraps and cornmeal, fried until crispy, remains a beloved breakfast item in the Delaware Valley, a true historical staple.
• Oyster Stew: Given the incredible abundance of oysters in the 18th and 19th centuries, oyster stew was a common, inexpensive, and hearty dish that frequently appeared on tables, especially around holidays. Its popularity has waned as oysters have become more of a gourmet item.

  ---

Philadelphia's forgotten foods offer a tantalizing glimpse into a bygone era of culinary ingenuity and local flavor. While some might seem unusual to modern palates, they represent the diverse ingredients and rich traditions that shaped the city's vibrant food scene, long before the cheesesteak became king.