CONNECTICUT, A state steeped in colonial history, is home to two towns that both lay claim to a prestigious title: the oldest English settlement in the state. Windsor, established in 1633, and Wethersfield, settled in 1634, have engaged in a long-standing, friendly rivalry over which can rightfully claim to be Connecticut's first town.
Windsor vs. Wethersfield: The Enduring Debate Over Connecticut's Oldest Town
This article explores the historical foundations of both Windsor and Wethersfield, delving into the nuances of their founding and the enduring debate over which deserves the title of "oldest."
Windsor's Claim: The First Trading Post (1633)
Windsor's claim centers on the establishment of a trading post in 1633. That year, Captain William Holmes and a group of men from the Plymouth Colony in Massachusetts sailed up the Connecticut River and established a trading post at the confluence of the Farmington and Connecticut Rivers, within the present-day boundaries of Windsor (Source: Windsor Historical Society, historical records of the Plymouth Colony). This marked the first documented English presence in Connecticut.
In 1637, Windsor was incorporated. In 1635, John Warham established a church and a government in Windsor.
Wethersfield's Counter-Claim: The First Permanent Settlement (1634)
Wethersfield's argument rests on the concept of permanent settlement. In 1634, John Oldham and a small group of settlers from Watertown, Massachusetts, arrived in the area that would become Wethersfield, establishing an agricultural community (Source: Wethersfield Historical Society, early colonial records of Connecticut). While the Windsor trading post predates this settlement, Wethersfield's advocates argue that their town represents the first continuous and permanent English settlement in Connecticut, with families establishing homes and farms.
The Heart of the Debate: Defining "Settlement"
The core of the Windsor-Wethersfield debate lies in the definition of "settlement."
- Windsor's Argument: Focuses on the initial presence of English settlers, with the 1633 trading post marking the first foothold.
- Wethersfield's Argument: Emphasizes continuous occupation and the establishment of a self-governing community, viewing the 1634 settlement as the true beginning of a permanent town.
A Friendly Rivalry: Two Towns, Rich Histories
The debate over Connecticut's oldest town is, for the most part, a friendly rivalry. Both Windsor and Wethersfield are proud of their early colonial heritage and offer visitors a glimpse into 17th-century New England life. Both towns have historical societies dedicated to preserving and promoting their respective histories.
The question of whether Windsor or Wethersfield is Connecticut's oldest town remains a matter of interpretation. Windsor can rightfully claim the first English trading post in 1633, while Wethersfield can argue for the first permanent English settlement in 1634. Rather than a definitive answer, the debate highlights the complexities of early colonial history and the different ways we can define a "town" or "settlement." Ultimately, both Windsor and Wethersfield offer invaluable contributions to Connecticut's rich historical tapestry, and exploring both towns provides a deeper understanding of the state's origins. The best approach is to appreciate both for their unique and significant roles in shaping Connecticut's early history.
Share This Article on Social Media
Sources:
- Windsor Historical Society
- Wethersfield Historical Society
- Connecticut State Library (for colonial records)
- Historical accounts of the Plymouth Colony and early Connecticut settlements
