Philadelphia, PA—Lancaster, Pennsylvania, is a city with some pretty amazing burgers. Lancaster's burger tradition is truly impressive, ranging from a down-to-earth spot featuring its own butcher to a gastropub that combines a New American kitchen with craft beer. Listed below are some of our favorite Places to grab a Great Burger in the City of Lancaster.
Best Burgers and Cheeseburgers in Lancaster, PA
For readers of PhillyBite Magazine and WherePhilly, hunting down the perfect patty is a serious endeavor. Lancaster, Pennsylvania, boasts a truly impressive burger tradition, from a down-to-earth eatery with its own whole-animal butcher to historic gastropubs that pair New American kitchens with local craft beer.
Cabalar Meat Co.
Operating as a whole-animal butcher and an incredibly popular local eatery, Cabalar takes their beef seriously. Because they source and grind their own meat, the burgers are flawlessly fresh and juicy, and you can order them with a perfect pink center. While the classic double-patty smash burgers are exceptional, the Steakhouse Burger—topped with marinated mushrooms, blue cheese, steak sauce, and arugula—is an absolute must-order.
325 N Queen St, Lancaster, PA 17603
Route 66 Restaurant
This 1950s-inspired diner is a local favorite offering timeless comfort food. Known for serving some of the best, crispiest smash burgers in the city, the uncomplicated, perfectly seasoned patties are ideal for stacking with melted American cheese. If you have the appetite, order the massive Quad Cheeseburger with a side of their highly rated mozzarella sticks or curly fries.
45 W Liberty St #2700, Lancaster, PA 17603
Horse Inn
Tucked away in a restored 1920s hayloft and speakeasy, this historic site offers refined pub fare, craft cocktails, and an incredible ambiance. The menu has only one burger, but it is the only one you need. The famous Horse Inn Cheeseburger features a custom blend of short rib, brisket, chuck, and 10% dry-aged beef. Topped simply with red onion, lettuce, tomato, white American cheese, and a signature sauce on a locally baked Alfred & Sam's bun, it is widely considered the best burger in the region.
540 E Fulton St, Lancaster, PA 17602
551 West
This multi-level tavern offers a homey, relaxed atmosphere that perfectly complements its excellent New American pub grub and craft beer selection. With multiple bars and a spacious patio, it is a fantastic spot to grab a pint and a hearty meal. Do not miss the Balsamic Bleu Burger—a thick, perfectly grilled patty piled high with sautéed mushrooms, caramelized onions, crumbled bleu cheese, and a sweet balsamic reduction.
551 W King St, Lancaster, PA 17603
Lancaster Dispensing Company (DipCo)
Located directly adjacent to the historic Central Market, this beloved downtown institution has been serving the community for over 30 years. While the menu offers a massive variety of casual fare, locals know to stop in for their specialty burgers. The signature Beer Burger, smothered in rich, house-made beer cheese and crispy bacon, pairs perfectly with their rotating selection of local craft drafts.
33-35 N Market St, Lancaster, PA 17603
Share Lancaster Burgers on Social Media
Written By: Philly Bite Magazine Staff
Pennsylvania's Best of Series features the top places to find great food, entertainment, and more.
