5 Best Cape May Coffee Shops and Cafes

Cape May's Daily Grind: A Guide to the Best Coffee Shops and Cafes

Cape May, New Jersey, is a town celebrated for its Victorian charm, pristine beaches, and a culinary scene that punches well above its weight. For locals and visitors alike, starting a day of exploring often begins with the perfect cup of coffee. Beyond just a morning caffeine fix, Cape May's coffee shops are destinations in themselves—cozy corners for conversation, bustling hubs of local life, and artisanal cafes dedicated to the craft of the perfect brew. From farm-fresh lattes to beachfront espressos, this guide will lead you to the must-visit coffee shops and cafes in America's oldest seaside resort.

1. Magic Brain Café

• The Vibe: Tucked inside the Carpenter's Square Mall, just steps from the beach, Magic Brain Café is a beloved local institution with a cozy, laid-back atmosphere. It’s the kind of welcoming, comfortable spot where you can relax with a book or catch up with friends. The owner is a constant, friendly presence, adding to the genuine neighborhood feel.

  
  
  

• The Coffee & More: They serve a fantastic cup of coffee and expertly crafted espresso drinks, with a wide array of syrup flavors to customize your order. Beyond the coffee, they are known for delicious baked goods, especially their scones.

• Location: 31 Perry St, Cape May, NJ 08204

  
  
  

2. Ostara's Coffee House

• The Vibe: Located in the charming area of West Cape May, Ostara's is a beautifully curated, family-owned coffee shop with an eclectic and welcoming vibe. It's particularly popular with families, thanks to a dedicated play area for children, allowing parents to enjoy their lattes in peace.

• The Coffee & More: Ostara's is a haven for those with dietary preferences, offering an excellent selection of gluten-free and vegan baked goods. They are also known for their creative and "Instagrammable" specialty lattes and a great selection of teas.

  
  
  

• Location: 600 Park Blvd, West Cape May, NJ 08204

3. Coffee Tyme

• The Vibe: A true Cape May staple, Coffee Tyme is a family-owned shop that has been voted "Best Coffee in Cape May" for multiple years. With two convenient locations—one on the bustling Washington Street Mall and another right on Beach Avenue—it's a go-to for both locals and tourists.

• The Coffee & More: They brew up to eight specialty coffees daily and are famous for their from-scratch pastries and breakfast sandwiches. Their blueberry muffins, bursting with fruit, are a local legend.

• Know Before You Go: This popular spot is often cash only, so be sure to have some on hand.

• Locations: 414 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204 & 315 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

4. Out There Coffee

• The Vibe: For the true coffee aficionado, Out There Coffee is a must-visit. This charming cafe has a warm, inviting atmosphere and a clear passion for high-quality, craft coffee.

• The Coffee & More: They proudly serve locally roasted, organic beans from Harry and Beans roasters. The menu features classic espresso drinks alongside unique "Superfood Lattes" with ingredients like turmeric and raw cacao. Their lattes are consistently praised as some of the best in the area.

• Location: 315 Ocean St, Unit #22, Cape May, NJ 08204

5. Beach Plum Farm Cafe

• The Vibe: For a truly unique and picturesque experience, the cafe at Beach Plum Farm is unparalleled. Located on a beautiful 62-acre working farm in West Cape May, this spot offers a genuine farm-to-table experience in a rustic and serene setting.

• The Coffee & More: Enjoy a cup of La Colombe coffee, including their popular Draft Latte on tap, paired with fresh baked goods made with ingredients sourced directly from the farm—often using eggs, herbs, and produce harvested that morning.

• Pro-Tip: After grabbing your coffee, take some time to wander the beautiful farm grounds and visit the market, which sells fresh produce, meats, and artisanal goods.

• Location: 484 West Perry Street, Cape May, NJ 08204

Written By: Philly Bite Magazines Staff

NJ's Best Of Series consists of a round-up of the best places to find great food, entertainment, and More.

Best Coffee in Cape May, NJ