WEST VIRGINIA - West Virginia is a state that excels at hearty, comforting fare, perfectly suited for cozy mountain towns and long drives through the Appalachian terrain. The humble grilled cheese sandwich is a staple here, often elevated with local cheeses, smoked meats, and regional specialties.
WEST VIRGINIA - West Virginia is a state that excels at hearty, comforting fare, perfectly suited for cozy mountain towns and long drives through the Appalachian terrain. The humble grilled cheese sandwich is a staple here, often elevated with local cheeses, smoked meats, and regional specialties.10 Must-visit Spots In West Virginia Serving Up Melts That Are Truly Magnificent
1. Cheese Louise (Morgantown)
This spot is often cited as a top contender for the state's best grilled cheese, known for its creative menu that puts the cheesy classic front and center.
Must-Try Melt: The West Virginia Hot Brown - A twist on the regional favorite, this melt combines thick-sliced turkey, bacon, and a rich, creamy Mornay sauce over Texas toast, sometimes served open-faced, always piled high with cheese.
2. Bluegrass Kitchen (Charleston)
Located in the state capital, Bluegrass Kitchen offers Appalachian-inspired comfort food with a sophisticated twist, utilizing high-quality, often locally sourced ingredients.
Must-Try Melt: The Farmhouse Grilled Cheese - Features a hearty blend of artisanal cheddar and Monterey Jack, often incorporating caramelized onions or house-made pickled components on thick, rustic bread.
3. Atomic Grill (Morgantown)
While famous for its barbecue, Atomic Grill applies its smoking expertise to its grilled cheese, giving the sandwich a savory depth few others can match.
Must-Try Melt: The Smoked Pulled Pork Melt - A delicious clash of cuisines, this sandwich layers tender, smoked pulled pork with sharp cheddar and a tangy BBQ sauce between buttered, grilled bread.
4. Black Sheep Burrito & Brews (Huntington & Charleston)
Known for its creative fusion menu, Black Sheep occasionally features a grilled cheese that incorporates bold, non-traditional Mexican-inspired flavors.
Must-Try Melt: The Chorizo Grilled Cheese - Features spicy chorizo sausage, Pepper Jack cheese, and possibly cilantro or avocado crema, turning the classic melt into a fiery, flavorful experience.
5. Secret Sandwich Society (Fayetteville)
A popular spot near the New River Gorge, this restaurant specializes in gourmet sandwiches, and its straightforward grilled cheese is executed flawlessly.
Must-Try Melt: The "Plain Jane" with Extras - The base is perfection—gooey, sharp cheese on golden, crispy bread—but ask to add local apple butter or a slice of house-cured bacon for a true Appalachian treat.
6. The Lunchbox (Clarksburg)
A classic, no-frills diner experience where the focus is on quick, satisfying, and reliable comfort food.
Must-Try Melt: The Classic Diner Melt - Simple American cheese on soft, griddled white bread, served with a perfect side of creamy tomato soup—nostalgia made real.
7. Mountain State Brewing Co. (Morgantown & Deep Creek)
This popular brewery and restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere and a menu designed to pair perfectly with their craft brews.
Must-Try Melt: The Pepperoni Roll Grilled Cheese - A nod to West Virginia's unofficial state food, this melt incorporates pepperoni and cheese (likely provolone or mozzarella) inside, grilled on a ciabatta or roll until crispy.
8. Oliverio's Ristorante (Morgantown)
Though primarily Italian, this restaurant occasionally features a grilled sandwich that utilizes Italian cheeses and fresh herbs, offering a Mediterranean twist.
Must-Try Melt: The Italian Melt - Mozzarella, Provolone, sun-dried tomatoes, and basil pesto grilled until the cheese stretches delightfully.
9. The Corner Shop (Fairmont)
A long-standing local favorite known for its friendly service and dependable, classic American cafe menu.
Must-Try Melt: The Pimento Cheese Grill - A creamy, house-made Southern pimento cheese spread melted between toasted bread—a simple, deeply satisfying regional staple.
10. Custard Stand (Multiple Locations)
While famous for its hot dogs and custard, this roadside favorite offers a surprisingly good traditional melt alongside its classic American fare.
Must-Try Melt: The Classic Cheddar Melt - Straightforward cheddar on buttered bread, providing the perfect balance of crisp, buttery exterior and sharp, gooey interior.
