Top 5 Best Philadelphia Bakeries for Pies

Philly's Pie Perfection: A Guide to the City's 5 Best Bakeries for Pies

Philadelphia is a city that loves its baked goods, and while it's famous for cheesecakes and cannolis, it also has a seriously impressive pie scene. From classic, flaky fruit pies and rich, decadent cream pies to savory British-style meat pies, the city's bakeries offer a delicious slice for every occasion. Whether you're planning for a holiday gathering or simply craving a comforting, homemade treat, here is a guide to five of the best and most beloved bakeries for pies in Philadelphia.

1. Stargazy (East Passyunk)

• The Vibe: A tiny, authentic British-style pie and mash shop, Stargazy has become a beloved and unique culinary destination in South Philadelphia.
• The Pie: This is the place for classic savory British pies. Their signature is the traditional Beef & Onion Pie, featuring tender meat in a rich gravy, all encased in a perfect, flaky pastry. They also offer other rotating savory pies, sausage rolls, and classic British desserts. It's a taste of London right on East Passyunk Avenue.
• Location: 1838 E Passyunk Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19148

2. The Bakeshop on 20th (Rittenhouse Square)

• The Vibe: A charming and cozy neighborhood bakeshop, The Bakeshop on 20th is a go-to for all things sweet and homemade. The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and always smells incredible.
• The Pie: While their entire menu is fantastic, their pies are a true standout. They offer a rotating selection of seasonal fruit pies (like apple crumb and mixed berry) and classic cream pies (like chocolate cream and key lime). They are known for their perfect, buttery, flaky crusts and high-quality fillings.
• Location: 269 S 20th St, Philadelphia, PA 19103

3. Beiler's Bakery (Reading Terminal Market)

• The Vibe: An iconic, bustling Amish bakery in the heart of the historic Reading Terminal Market, Beiler's is a must-visit for any tourist or local. While famous for their donuts, their pies are equally legendary.
• The Pie: This is the destination for classic Pennsylvania Dutch-style pies. Look for incredible Shoofly Pie, classic Apple Pie, and a wide variety of other fruit and cream pies, all made with a commitment to traditional, homestyle quality.
• Location: 51 N 12th St, Philadelphia, PA 19107

4. Sweet T's Bakery & Snack Shop (South Philadelphia)

• The Vibe: A beloved bakery specializing in Southern-style desserts, Sweet T's is a go-to for rich and comforting baked goods.
• The Pie: They are particularly famous for their incredible sweet potato pie, which is considered by many to be the best in the city. The filling is perfectly spiced, sweet, and creamy, with a delicious crust. They also offer a fantastic 7-Up pound cake and other Southern classics.
• Location: 5150 Germantown Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19144 (Note: This is in Germantown, not South Philly, but is a Philly legend).

5. Linvilla Orchards (Media, PA - Worth the Drive)

• The Vibe: While a short drive from the city, no Pennsylvania pie list is complete without Linvilla Orchards. This massive, family-friendly farm is a regional institution, especially in the fall.
• The Pie: Their farm market bakery produces thousands of pies, and they are famous for their classic "Dutch Apple Crumb" pie, which is piled high with fresh apples from their own orchard and a sweet, buttery crumb topping. They offer over 40 varieties of pies throughout the year.
• Location: 137 W Knowlton Rd, Media, PA 19063

From the savory British classics at Stargazy and the seasonal fruit pies at The Bakeshop on 20th to the iconic sweet potato pie at Sweet T's and the traditional Dutch creations at Beiler's, Philadelphia and its surrounding areas offer a world-class pie experience. These top-tier bakeries showcase the incredible craftsmanship and diverse culinary traditions that make the region's pie scene so delicious.

Share Philly Pies on Social Media

Joy Franklin
Food and Event Writer
My joy is aimed at food and foodie lovers. I enjoy covering trends, issues, and all things Philly