Where to Find The Best Whoopie Pies?

Pennsylvania's Sweetest Tradition: Where to Find the Best Whoopie Pies

The whoopie pie is a beloved and iconic American dessert, and its heartland is undeniably in Eastern and Central Pennsylvania. This classic treat, born from the kitchens of the Pennsylvania Dutch and Amish communities, is a perfect comfort food: two soft, cake-like cookies sandwiching a generous layer of sweet, creamy filling. Whether you're a purist who loves the classic chocolate-and-vanilla combination or a fan of more modern flavors, the Keystone State offers a delicious journey for any whoopie pie enthusiast. This expert guide, based on deep local knowledge and extensive research, will lead you to the best spots to find this treasured confection.

The Epicenter: Lancaster County

For the most authentic whoopie pie experience, a trip to Lancaster County is a must. This is where the tradition began, and you'll find incredible, homemade versions at bakeries, farm stands, and markets throughout the region.

1. Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop

• The Vibe: Located in the heart of Amish Country, the Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop is a legendary destination for homemade baked goods. It's a charming, bustling shop where you can find a huge array of traditional Pennsylvania Dutch treats.

• The Whoopie Pie: They have been making whoopie pies since 1978, using family recipes passed down through generations. They are known for their jumbo-sized pies with an extra smooth and creamy filling. In addition to the classic chocolate, they offer fantastic seasonal flavors like pumpkin and red velvet.

  
  
  

• Location: 542 Gibbons Rd, Bird in Hand, PA 17505

2. S. Clyde Weaver (East Petersburg, PA & various markets)

• The Vibe: A Lancaster County institution since 1920, S. Clyde Weaver is a renowned smokehouse and market, famous for its high-quality meats and cheeses. Their bakery section is equally impressive.

  
  
  

• The Whoopie Pie: They offer fantastic whoopie pies, and their pumpkin whoopie pie with cream cheese filling is a particular standout, beloved for its authentic, rich flavor. They also have a popular stand at the Lancaster Central Market.

3. Roadside Farm Stands

• The Vibe: One of the best ways to experience a true Lancaster County whoopie pie is to stop at one of the many Amish and Mennonite-run roadside farm stands that dot the countryside.

• The Whoopie Pie: These are often the most authentic, made with simple, high-quality ingredients from family recipes. Keep an eye out for hand-painted signs as you drive through the backroads of Lancaster County—you're sure to find a delicious, fresh-baked treasure.

Philadelphia's Best

You don't have to leave the city to find a fantastic whoopie pie. Philadelphia's most famous food hall is home to some top-tier options.

4. Beiler's Bakery (Reading Terminal Market)

• The Vibe: An iconic Amish bakery in the heart of the bustling Reading Terminal Market, Beiler's is a must-visit for any tourist or local. While world-famous for their incredible donuts, their whoopie pies are equally legendary.

• The Whoopie Pie: This is the place for a classic Pennsylvania Dutch-style whoopie pie. Expect big, soft chocolate cake-cookies bursting with sweet, creamy frosting. They also offer other delicious flavors like pumpkin and red velvet.

5. Flying Monkey Bakery (Reading Terminal Market)

• The Vibe: Another beloved bakery in the Reading Terminal Market, Flying Monkey is a sweet sensation known for its creative and delicious baked goods made from scratch in small batches.

• The Whoopie Pie: They are famous for putting their own creative spin on the classic whoopie pie, offering a variety of interesting and inventive flavors that go beyond the traditional. It's a great spot to try a more modern take on this Pennsylvania favorite.

Disclaimer: Please note that hours for bakeries and markets, especially smaller farm stands, can vary seasonally. It's always a good idea to check their operational status before planning a visit.

Share This Article on Social Media