SEA ISLE CITY - If you're looking for a relaxed, family-friendly waterfront meal away from the bustle of the boardwalk, Sunset Pier Restaurant & Juice Bar at 86th Street and the Bay in Sea Isle City is a true hidden gem. Offering classic American fare from sunup to sundown in an unpretentious bayside space, this spot combines generous portions, reasonable prices, and some of the best sunset views on the island.
A Casual Waterfront Atmosphere with Excellent Service
Whether you grab a table inside the cozy dining room or out on their roomy deck, the atmosphere here is pure shore comfort. The views over the back bay are gorgeous—especially on a cool summer evening as the boats roll by and the sun drops over the water. Throughout our visit, the service was friendly, welcoming, and impressively efficient, making the whole experience feel relaxed from start to finish.
Breakfast Favorites and the Fresh Juice Bar
Sunset Pier has earned a loyal morning following for good reason. They serve hearty breakfast options that hit every craving:
- Multigrain Pancakes: A standout favorite—fluffy, wholesome, and delicious when piled high with fresh fruit.
- Loaded Omelets: Perfectly cooked, generously stuffed, and served hot and fast.
- The Juice Bar: If you're looking for a lighter, healthier start before hitting the beach, their juice bar options are fresh, revitalizing, and a fantastic touch for a bayside diner.
Fresh Local Seafood & Evening Comforts
When evening rolls around, the kitchen pivots to vibrant pasta dishes and fresh, local seafood that rival those of the fancier, higher-priced spots in town. Favorites among diners include:
- Crab & Spinach Dip: Rich, creamy, and loaded with crab—a must-order appetizer for the table.
- Blackened Mahi: Cooked with just the right amount of spice and served fresh.
- Broiled Seafood Combo: A generous, perfectly prepared platter that lets the natural flavor of the seafood shine.
Pro-Tips for Visiting: Cash Only & Evening Hours
Before you head over, keep two important logistics in mind:
- Bring Cash: Sunset Pier operates on a cash-only policy, so make sure to hit the ATM before you arrive!
- Check the Dinner Hours: They are open daily from 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM for breakfast and lunch. For dinner, they open 5:00 PM – 9:00 PM Sunday through Friday, but are closed on Saturdays.
Between the waterfront deck, friendly staff, reasonable prices, and delicious sea-to-table comfort food, Sunset Pier is easily one of Sea Isle's best-kept secrets. Highly recommend grabbing a deck table and catching a sunset here!
Share This Article on Social Media