The 10-Pound Pizza Challenge: NJ’s Craziest Food Face-Offs for 2026

The 10-Pound Pizza Challenge

The 10-Pound Pizza Challenge

Eat
Typography
  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

The 10-Pound Pizza ChallengeNEW JERSEY - New Jersey has long been the land of "Fat Sandwiches" and massive diners, but in 2026, the State food scene is taking "over-the-top" to a whole new level. These aren't just meals; they are culinary gauntlets designed to test the limits of human endurance, spice tolerance, and stomach capacity.


If you're looking to make a name for yourself on a Wall of Fame this year, here are the five most viral food challenges currently sweeping the Garden State.

1. The Colossal Grandma Pizza Sandwich (Genova Pizza, Audubon)

This is the one that has been blowing up on TikTok. Forget a standard sandwich—Genova Pizza in Audubon takes two entire 16-inch Grandma-style pizzas and uses them as the "bread."



  • The Filling: In between those two massive pizzas is a mountain of cheesesteak meat, chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, bacon, and fries, all drenched in sauce.
  • The Stats: It weighs in at roughly 10 pounds.
  • The Prize: If you and a partner can finish this beast in under an hour, you get the $100+ meal for free, a custom T-shirt, and your photo permanently etched into South Jersey legend.

2. The Phaal Curry Challenge (Brick Lane Curry House, Jersey City)

For those who prefer heat over volume, the Phaal Challenge is the "Mount Everest" of spice. This dish is notoriously recognized as the hottest curry in the world.

  • The Warning: The fumes from the multiple ghost peppers and Carolina Reapers used in the sauce are so intense that the chefs must wear gas masks while cooking it. You are required to sign a physical waiver before your first bite.
  • The Prize: Survivors get a free beer to extinguish the flames and a spot on the "Phaal of Fame."

3. The "8th Wonder" Burger (Clinton Station Diner, Clinton)

If you have nine hungry friends and a competitive spirit, the Clinton Station Diner has a challenge that requires a team effort.



  • The Stats: The "8th Wonder" is a staggering 105-pound burger.
  • The Rules: A team of 10 people has exactly one hour to consume the entire thing.
  • The Prize: If your team manages the impossible, you walk away with a $2,000 cash prize. (Spoiler: It has been attempted hundreds of times with only a handful of successes.

4. The "Fat Sandwich" Marathon (RU Hungry?, New Brunswick)

No NJ food list is complete without the birthplace of the Fat Sandwich. While eating one "Fat Darrell" is a rite of passage, the official challenge is much steeper.

  • The Challenge: You must consume five original Fat Sandwiches in 45 minutes or less.
  • The Prize: Not only is the meal free, but you earn the ultimate Jersey honor: the right to create and name your own sandwich that will be added to the permanent menu.

5. The "Satan's Hell Stick" Challenge (Tony BBoloney's Multiple Locations)

Tony Boloney's is famous for its Taco Pizza, but its 2026 viral hit is much more painful.



  • The Dish: Five mozzarella sticks infused with an 11-million Scoville unit "Satan Ranch" and topped with ghost pepper and reaper dust.
  • The Catch: It's not just about eating them; you have to endure a five-minute "burn period" after finishing, where you are not allowed to drink water, milk, or even wipe your face.

Are You Ready to Face the Feast?

Before you attempt any of these, experts recommend "stretching" your stomach with high-water-volume foods (like watermelon) in the days leading up to a volume challenge, or building up a capsaicin tolerance for the Phaal.

Would you like me to find the nearest location for these challenges or draft a "Team Recruitment" post for your friends to tackle the 105-pound burger?

 
 

Latest Posts

Sign up via our free email subscription service to receive notifications when new information is available.

Sponsered Ads



Follow PhillyBite:

Follow Our Socials Below