10 Best Bars in Cape May to Grab a Drink

A Guide to Cape May's Best Bars: From Historic Taverns to Beachfront Grills

Cape May, New Jersey, is a town that exudes historic charm and seaside elegance, and its vibrant bar scene is a perfect reflection of this character. Whether you're looking for a sophisticated cocktail in a grand hotel, a cold beer at a legendary surf bar, or a pint of Guinness in a classic Irish pub, this beloved shore town has a perfect spot to suit your mood. From lively beachfront decks to cozy, historic taverns, here is a guide to the best and most beloved bars in Cape May.

Historic & Classic Taverns

1. The Ebbitt Room at The Virginia Hotel

• The Vibe: The pinnacle of Cape May elegance, The Ebbitt Room is located in the historic Virginia Hotel. The bar area is sophisticated and intimate, with a classic, clubby feel. It's the perfect spot for a quiet, expertly crafted cocktail before or after dinner.
• The Experience: Known for its farm-to-table cuisine, the bar offers a fantastic selection of classic cocktails, an extensive wine list, and a refined atmosphere.

2. The Washington Inn & Wine Bar

• The Vibe: Housed in a beautifully restored 1840s plantation house, The Washington Inn offers a romantic and historic setting. The wine bar is cozy and elegant, perfect for a special evening.
• The Experience: They boast an award-winning wine list with hundreds of selections. It's an ideal location to enjoy a fine glass of wine, perhaps by a cozy fireside table or on the beautiful summer patio.

3. Mayer's Tavern

• The Vibe: A true local institution, Mayer's Tavern is a friendly, no-frills neighborhood spot with a warm and inviting atmosphere. It's a place where locals and visitors comfortably mingle.
• The Experience: While the menu has been modernized to reflect the local seafood scene, the vibe remains classic. It's a fantastic place to grab a drink, enjoy some delicious small plates, and soak in the authentic Cape May character.

4. Delaney's Irish Pub And Grill

• The Vibe: For a classic, casual Irish pub experience, Delaney's is a go-to. It's a relaxed neighborhood spot with great food, a full bar, and plenty of TVs, making it a great place to watch a game.
• The Experience: Enjoy a perfectly poured pint of Guinness, a hearty pub meal, and a friendly, laid-back atmosphere.

Lively Beach & Grille Bars

5. Harry's Ocean Bar & Grille

• The Vibe: Located right on the beachfront with a popular rooftop bar, Harry's is a high-energy spot with incredible ocean views and frequent live music.
• The Experience: This is a quintessential summer destination. Enjoy seafood, sandwiches, and fantastic cocktails while taking in the stunning panorama of the Atlantic.

6. The Rusty Nail

• The Vibe: A legendary surf bar and restaurant, The Rusty Nail at the Beach Shack hotel is the definition of casual, laid-back beach fun. With its sand floor, fire pits, and live entertainment, it's a perfect spot to unwind after a day on the beach.
• The Experience: Famous for its fun, relaxed atmosphere and its dog-friendly policy. It's a place where you can literally have your toes in the sand while you sip your drink.

7. Fins Bar & Grille

• The Vibe: Located right on the Washington Street Mall, Fins is a modern and lively spot with a great atmosphere. It's perfect for families and anyone looking for a fun, casual meal and drink in the heart of town.
• The Experience: Known for its good food, top-notch service, and a great selection of drinks. Its central location makes it a convenient and popular choice.

Unique Hotel Bars

8. The Brown Room at Congress Hall

• The Vibe: A sophisticated and iconic lounge inside the grand and historic Congress Hall hotel. The Brown Room is a beautifully appointed space with a classic, clubby feel, often featuring live piano music.
• The Experience: It's the perfect spot for a classic, expertly made cocktail in an elegant and historic setting.

9. Elaine's Cape May

• The Vibe: Elaine's offers a unique combination of a classy boutique hotel, a restaurant, and a popular outdoor bar and porch.
• The Experience: The bar is a great spot to enjoy a drink in a beautiful setting. Their happy hour, often held on Wednesdays, is a local favorite, featuring special drinks and half-off appetizers.

10. King Edward Bar

• The Vibe: Known affectionately as the "King Eddie," this lively bar is located in the historic Chalfonte Hotel. It has a fun, Southern-inspired porch bar feel.
• The Experience: It's a fantastic spot to grab a drink, listen to live music, and enjoy the classic, old-world charm of one of Cape May's original hotels.

Share This Article on Social Media

Joy Franklin
Food and Event Writer
My joy is aimed at food and foodie lovers. I enjoy covering trends, issues, and all things Philly.