11 Must-Try Philly Cheesesteaks in New Jersey

Discover Delicious Cheesesteak Joints in South Jersey

1. Donkey's Place in Camden

Donkey's Place in Camden is more than just a restaurant. It's a local institution serving up its famous cheesesteaks for over 70 years. When you step inside, you're immediately transported to a lively, down-home atmosphere where locals gather to enjoy a delicious meal. The show's star is their cheesesteak, served on a soft and chewy poppy seed bun, perfectly complemented by a generous portion of thinly sliced ribeye steak cooked to perfection. The meat is tender and flavorful, packed with smoky goodness that will make your taste buds dance with delight. And what's a cheesesteak without a side of crispy french fries? Donkey's Place delivers on that front, too, offering a side that perfectly complements the sandwich. Located at 1223 Haddon Ave, Donkey's Place is not just a place to grab a bite to eat—it's an experience you won't soon forget.

2. Peter & Sons Sandwiches in Glassboro

Peter & Sons Sandwiches in Glassboro is a hidden gem of South Jersey cheesesteak joints. Owned and operated by Peter and his family, this cozy little spot is dedicated to bringing the flavors of Peter's upbringing to the Garden State. With a menu that pays homage to classic Italian-American cuisine, Peter & Sons Sandwiches is the perfect place to indulge in a delicious cheesesteak. Located at 20 Delsea Dr, this eatery is a local favorite, renowned for its friendly service and mouthwatering sandwiches.

3. Skyler's Hoagies in Mt Laurel Township

Skyler's Hoagies in Mt Laurel Township is a must-visit spot for any cheesesteak enthusiast. This family-owned eatery offers a variety of giant hoagies and cheesesteaks, all at affordable prices. The quality and service at Skyler's Hoagies are exceptional, making it a standout among the countless sandwich shops in the area. Skyler's Hoagies has something for everyone, whether you're craving a classic cheesesteak or something more adventurous. Pay them a visit at 1200 S Church St and prepare to be blown away by their incredible selection.

4. Voltaco's Italian Foods in Ocean City

Voltaco's Italian Foods in Ocean City is the go-to spot for anyone searching for authentic Italian flavors in their cheesesteak. A longstanding favorite among locals, this carry-out spot is known for its specialty pizzas, hot Italian subs, and mouthwatering cheesesteak subs. Voltaco's doesn't hold back when it comes to their sandwiches—they pile on the thick cuts of meat and pack every bite with full-bodied flavor. At 957 West Ave, Voltaco's Italian Foods is the perfect place to satisfy your Italian cheesesteak cravings.

5. The Speakeatery in Asbury Park

The Speakeatery in Asbury Park may be small, but don't let that fool you—it packs an enormous punch for sandwiches, including its excellent chicken cheesesteaks. Tucked away on Cookman Ave, this takeout-only spot offers some of the best cheesesteaks on the Jersey Shore. The super soft roll, with tender chicken and a medley of flavorful toppings, creates an irresistible sandwich. So, if you find yourself in Asbury Park, swing by the Speakeatery at 705 Cookman Ave and grab a sandwich that will have you coming back for more.

6. White House Sub Shop in Atlantic City

White House Sub Shop in Atlantic City has been a must-visit destination for over seven decades. Since its opening in 1946, this legendary establishment has drawn crowds from near and far, including celebrities who can't resist their vast and delicious cheesesteaks. Located at 2301 Arctic Ave, this no-frills joint focuses on one thing and one thing only—serving up the perfect cheesesteak. And they deliver a flavorful masterpiece that will leave you wanting more. Visiting the White House Sub Shop is essential for anyone looking to experience an authentic taste of Atlantic City.

7. Brynn Bradley in Woodbury

Brynn Bradley, located at 839 N. Broad St., Woodbury, New Jersey, offers a modern take on cheesesteaks that appeals to the new generation of cheesesteak enthusiasts. Founded in late 2020 by chef Matthew Hartnett, Brynn Bradley's cheesesteaks are made with high-quality ingredients. They use freshly baked Seeded Liscio's rolls, sixteen ounces of in-house shaved ribeye cooked to medium, and generous amounts of well-distributed Cooper Sharp cheese. The onions are finely chopped and evenly distributed within the roll.

8. Fat Daddy's in Lafayette Twp

Fat Daddy's, situated at 191 Rte. 15, Lafayette Twp., offers a unique twist to the classic cheesesteak. Their menu includes a make-your-own pizza cheesesteak with mozzarella, marinara, and garlic seasoning. They also have the Jersey cheesesteak, which features American cheese, lettuce, tomato, raw onion, butter, and garlic. In addition, Fat Daddy's offers other options like Fat Sandwiches and a variety of mac and cheese dishes.

9. Corson's Steaks in Haddonfield

Corson's Steaks, found at 14 Tanner St., Haddonfield, New Jersey, is a relatively new player in the cheesesteak scene, having opened in November. However, chef Mark Rooks has quickly established Corson's Steaks as a strong contender with their distinctive new-school steak. It's made with sliced ribeye and topped with sweetly caramelized onions. Corson's operates on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays only.

10. The Original Gaetano's in Hamilton

The Original Gaetano's at 1280 Rte. 33, Hamilton, is known for its wide selection of cheesesteaks, offering nearly three dozen varieties. Among their popular choices is the Peter Piper, an award-winning option made with green, sweet, roasted peppers, jalapeno, and hot peppers. They also have over a dozen types of chicken steaks available. The Original Gaetano's also gained recognition as a top-5 finisher in the first Philadelphia Cheesesteak Festival.

11. Cheesesteak Louie's in Seaside Heights

If you find yourself in Ocean County and crave a juicy cheesesteak, look no further than Cheesesteak Louie's in Seaside Heights. This local favorite is highly recommended by friends, and local cheesesteak lovers. At 22 Boulevard, Cheesesteak Louie's is the perfect spot to indulge in a cheesy, meaty, and satisfying sandwich that will leave you returning for more.

Share This Article on Social Media