11 Best Philly Cheesesteaks in New Jersey

Discovering Delicious Cheesesteak Joints in South Jersey

While Philadelphia holds the undisputed crown for inventing the cheesesteak, its South Jersey neighbors have perfected their own distinct, mouthwatering versions of this iconic sandwich. From old-school institutions to modern takes, the Garden State offers a surprising array of exceptional cheesesteak joints that are well worth the trip across the Delaware. Get ready to embark on a delectable journey to discover South Jersey's finest.

1. Donkey's Place (Camden): More than just a bar, Donkey's Place is a Camden institution, serving its legendary cheesesteaks for over 70 years. Stepping inside transports you to a lively, down-home atmosphere where locals gather for a truly special meal. The star of the show is their cheesesteak, uniquely served on a soft and chewy poppy seed bun. This perfectly complements the generous portion of thinly sliced, perfectly cooked ribeye steak. The meat is tender, flavorful, and packed with smoky goodness. Don't forget a side of their crispy french fries to complete this unforgettable experience. Find this local legend at 1223 Haddon Ave.

   
   
   

2. Peter & Sons Sandwiches (Glassboro): A hidden gem in Glassboro, Peter & Sons Sandwiches brings the authentic flavors of Peter's Italian-American upbringing to South Jersey. This cozy, family-owned spot is dedicated to crafting delicious cheesesteaks that pay homage to classic culinary traditions. Known for its friendly service and mouthwatering sandwiches, Peter & Sons is a beloved local favorite. Visit them at 20 Delsea Dr for a taste of their homestyle creations.

3. Skyler's Hoagies (Mt Laurel Township): For any serious cheesesteak enthusiast in Mt Laurel Township, Skyler's Hoagies is a mandatory stop. This family-owned eatery prides itself on offering a variety of giant hoagies and cheesesteaks, all at incredibly affordable prices. The exceptional quality of ingredients and friendly service make Skyler's a standout. Whether you crave a classic cheesesteak or something more adventurous, Skyler's Hoagies, located at 1200 S Church St, promises to impress.

   
   
   

4. Voltaco's Italian Foods (Ocean City): For those seeking authentic Italian flair in their cheesesteak, Voltaco's Italian Foods in Ocean City is the go-to destination. A cherished local favorite for years, this carry-out spot is famed for its specialty pizzas, hot Italian subs, and, of course, its robust cheesesteak subs. Voltaco's doesn't shy away from generosity, piling on thick cuts of flavorful meat, ensuring every bite is packed with full-bodied taste. Head to 957 West Ave to satisfy your Italian cheesesteak cravings.

5. The Speakeatery (Asbury Park): Don't let the small size of The Speakeatery in Asbury Park fool you; it packs an enormous punch when it comes to sandwiches, particularly its excellent chicken cheesesteaks. This takeout-only spot, tucked away on Cookman Ave, consistently delivers some of the best cheesesteaks on the Jersey Shore. Their super soft rolls are loaded with tender chicken and a medley of flavorful toppings, creating an irresistible sandwich. If you're in Asbury Park, swing by 705 Cookman Ave for a sandwich that guarantees a return visit.

   
   
   

6. White House Sub Shop (Atlantic City): A true Atlantic City icon for over seven decades, White House Sub Shop has been a must-visit destination since 1946. This legendary establishment draws crowds from across the globe, including celebrities who can't resist their vast and delicious cheesesteaks. Located at 2301 Arctic Ave, this no-frills joint focuses intently on serving up the perfect cheesesteak, delivering a flavorful masterpiece that consistently leaves patrons craving more. A visit to the White House Sub Shop is an essential part of experiencing the authentic taste of Atlantic City.

7. Brynn Bradley (Woodbury): Brynn Bradley, at 839 N. Broad St., Woodbury, offers a modern, elevated take on cheesesteaks that appeals to a new generation of enthusiasts. Founded in late 2020 by Chef Matthew Hartnett, Brynn Bradley's cheesesteaks are crafted with high-quality ingredients. They feature freshly baked Seeded Liscio's rolls, a generous sixteen ounces of in-house shaved ribeye cooked to a perfect medium, and abundant, well-distributed Cooper Sharp cheese. Even the onions are finely chopped and evenly mixed throughout the roll, ensuring a balanced, delicious bite every time.

8. Fat Daddy's (Lafayette Twp): Situated at 191 Rte. 15, Lafayette Twp., Fat Daddy's provides a unique twist on the classic cheesesteak. Their imaginative menu includes a "make-your-own pizza cheesesteak" featuring mozzarella, marinara, and garlic seasoning. Another standout is the "Jersey cheesesteak," which comes loaded with American cheese, crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, raw onion, butter, and garlic. Beyond their innovative cheesesteaks, Fat Daddy's also offers indulgent "Fat Sandwiches" and a variety of comforting mac and cheese dishes.

9. Corson's Steaks (Haddonfield): Corson's Steaks, a relatively new player in the Haddonfield cheesesteak scene since its November opening, has quickly made a name for itself. Chef Mark Rooks has established Corson's with a distinctive "new-school" steak, crafted with thinly sliced ribeye and topped with sweetly caramelized onions that add a perfect counterpoint to the savory meat. Be sure to plan your visit, as Corson's operates exclusively on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays.

10. The Original Gaetano's (Hamilton): Found at 1280 Rte. 33, Hamilton, The Original Gaetano's is renowned for its expansive selection of cheesesteaks, boasting nearly three dozen varieties. Among their most celebrated options is the Peter Piper, an award-winning choice featuring a flavorful blend of green, sweet roasted peppers, jalapeños, and hot peppers. They also offer over a dozen types of chicken steaks. The Original Gaetano's has garnered significant recognition, including a top-5 finish in the inaugural Philadelphia Cheesesteak Festival.

11. Cheesesteak Louie's (Seaside Heights): For anyone in Ocean County craving a juicy cheesesteak, Cheesesteak Louie's in Seaside Heights comes highly recommended by locals and friends alike. Situated at 22 Boulevard, this local favorite is the perfect spot to indulge in a cheesy, meaty, and utterly satisfying sandwich that is sure to leave you planning your next visit before you've even finished your current one.

Share This Article on Social Media