9 Must-Try Comfort Food's In Gettysburg

A Taste of Comfort: A Guide to Gettysburg's Best Comfort Food

While Gettysburg is world-famous for its historic battlefields, it's also a destination with a rich and satisfying culinary scene that's perfect for when you crave a comforting meal. From historic taverns serving classic dishes to cozy pubs and down-home country restaurants, the area is packed with warming, indulgent, and delicious food. If you're looking for a meal that feels like a warm hug, here is a guide to some of the best comfort food dishes in and around Gettysburg.

1. Baked King's Onion Soup at Dobbin House Tavern

• The Dish: Nothing is more comforting than a classic onion soup, and the version at the historic Dobbin House Tavern is legendary. Their Baked King's Onion Soup is a rich beef broth packed with sweet onions and topped with a thick layer of savory, perfectly melted cheeses.
• The Vibe: Dining at the Dobbin House, which dates back to 1776, is an experience in itself. Enjoy your soup by candlelight in the rustic, colonial-era tavern for a true taste of history.
• Location: 89 Steinwehr Ave, Gettysburg, PA 17325

2. Shepherd's Pie at The Garryowen Irish Pub

• The Dish: The Garryowen Irish Pub serves an incredibly authentic Shepherd's Pie based on a traditional Irish family recipe. It features seasoned ground beef in a rich gravy, topped with a fluffy, lightly browned crown of mashed potatoes.
• The Vibe: A lively and authentic Irish pub in the heart of downtown Gettysburg, offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere, a great selection of Irish whiskeys, and often, live music.
• Location: 12 Chambersburg St, Gettysburg, PA 17325

3. Mile-High Meatloaf at Appalachian Brewing Company

• The Dish: Appalachian Brewing Company takes the classic meatloaf dinner to a new level. Their Mile-High Meatloaf features a thick slice of Black Angus meatloaf served on Texas toast, smothered in a stout-infused gravy, and topped with crispy fried onion straws.
• The Vibe: A spacious and family-friendly brewpub with a full menu and a fantastic selection of house-made craft beers and sodas to pair with your comforting meal.
• Location: 259 Steinwehr Ave, Gettysburg, PA 17325

4. Chicken Pot Pie at the Farnsworth House Inn

• The Dish: The Farnsworth House, an iconic and reputedly haunted inn that housed Confederate sharpshooters during the battle, serves a delicious, traditional Pennsylvania Dutch-style Chicken Pot Pie. It's a hearty and comforting dish made with egg noodles, potatoes, and tender chicken, all topped with a flaky, golden-baked crust.
• The Vibe: A unique opportunity to dine in a building steeped in Civil War history. The atmosphere is historic, cozy, and full of character.
• Location: 401 Baltimore St, Gettysburg, PA 17325

5. Crab Mac and Cheese at One Lincoln

• The Dish: Located in the historic Gettysburg Hotel, One Lincoln offers an upscale take on a comfort food classic with its Crab Mac and Cheese. This comforting bowl of goodness features freshly cooked macaroni coated in a creamy crab béchamel and topped with crispy brioche croutons.
• The Vibe: A sophisticated yet comfortable setting in the heart of Lincoln Square, perfect for a more refined dining experience.
• Location: 1 Lincoln Square, Gettysburg, PA 17325

6. Chili at Gettysburg Eddie's

• The Dish: There's nothing better on a cool day than a warm bowl of chili, and Gettysburg Eddie's serves an epic version. Their chili comes in a generous portion, topped with melted Monterey Jack and cheddar cheeses and crisp red onions, and is served with a piece of grilled garlic bread for dipping.
• The Vibe: A fun, casual, family-friendly restaurant and sports bar dedicated to Hall of Fame pitcher and Gettysburg native, Eddie Plank.
• Location: 217 Steinwehr Ave, Gettysburg, PA 17325

7. Apple Cider Donuts at Thirsty Farmer Brew Works

• The Dish: Sometimes comfort comes in the form of a sweet treat. Thirsty Farmer Brew Works, located in the heart of Adams County's "Apple Country," makes incredible warm apple cider donuts tossed in cinnamon sugar.
• The Vibe: A beautiful farm brewery with a rustic and relaxed atmosphere. Enjoy your donuts with their locally produced hard ciders and craft beers.
• Location: 290 Cashtown Rd, Biglerville, PA 17307

8. Crab Fries at The Blue and Gray Bar & Grill

• The Dish: A classic local favorite, the Blue and Gray Bar & Grill serves up a must-try comfort snack: Crab Fries. A heaping portion of their crispy fries is smothered in a warm, delicious, and cheesy crab dip.
• The Vibe: A casual and friendly sports bar that's a popular gathering spot for locals.
• Location: 2 Baltimore St, Gettysburg, PA 17325

9. Family-Style Dinner at Hickory Bridge Farm Restaurant

• The Dish: For the ultimate home-cooking experience, head to Hickory Bridge Farm. On weekends, they offer a family-style meal at private dining tables. The rotating menu includes entrees of two types of meat (often featuring their legendary Crab Imperial) alongside a variety of delicious sides, dessert, and beverages.
• The Vibe: A charming and rustic restaurant set in a historic barn on a beautiful farm just outside of Gettysburg. It's a truly unique and memorable dining experience. Reservations are often required.
• Location: 96 Hickory Bridge Rd, Orrtanna, PA 17353

Share This Article on Social Media