Philadelphia, PA
-Whether you're looking for a quick or a big slice, there are many places to satisfy your cravings for a slice of pizza in New Jersey. Many residents and pizza makers are known for their ardent devotion to their neighborhood pizzerias and joints, and most Jersey locals have their favorite spots. While there are many styles to choose from, New Jersey's best pizza is truly regional, and not everyone will enjoy the same thing.
New Jersey lies in the heart of what is affectionately known as America's "Pizza Belt," and its residents are famously passionate about their local pizzerias. The Garden State boasts a world-class pizza culture that is deeply rooted in its Italian-American heritage, with a diverse landscape of styles from the historic "tomato pies" of Trenton to classic, thin-crust tavern pies. This expert guide, based on decades of tradition and local acclaim, will lead you to five of the best and most iconic pizza destinations in New Jersey.
1. DeLorenzo's Tomato Pies (Robbinsville)
For a true taste of New Jersey's most unique contribution to the pizza world, a visit to DeLorenzo's Tomato Pies is a must. This legendary, family-run institution is a standard-bearer for the historic Trenton "tomato pie," a style where crushed tomatoes are ladled on top of the cheese and toppings. Their signature is an incredibly crispy, cracker-thin crust that has earned a fiercely loyal following for generations. While the tomato pie is the main attraction, the menu also features seasonal salads and other Italian classics in a bustling, family-friendly atmosphere.
2. Tacconelli's Pizzeria (Maple Shade)
A South Jersey outpost of the iconic Philadelphia original, Tacconelli's Pizzeria in Maple Shade has become a legend in its own right. This cash-only establishment is renowned for its signature thin-crust pizza, which has a unique, slightly chewy, and bread-like texture. The pies are crafted with fresh cheese, robust sauces, and high-quality toppings. A key part of the experience is their time-honored tradition: you must call ahead to "reserve your dough" for the day, ensuring every pizza served is fresh and accounted for.
3. Conte's Pizza and Bar (Princeton)
A beloved, classic tavern that has been a Princeton community hub for decades, Conte's is the ideal spot to gather with friends for a great pizza and a cold beer. This lively, cavernous spot is famous for its exceptionally thin and crispy tavern-style pizza. The old-fashioned decor, friendly staff, and the constant buzz of a happy crowd make it the perfect place to watch a game and enjoy a perfectly shareable pie that has earned a devoted local following.
4. Tony's Baltimore Grille (Atlantic City)
An absolute Atlantic City icon, Tony's Baltimore Grille has been serving its famous pizza and authentic Italian-American fare since 1927. This historic eatery, located in the heart of the city, is a warm and inviting spot that has remained a beloved constant through all of AC's changes. Their pizza is a classic, comforting, and delicious shore tradition, with a recipe that has remained unchanged for decades. It's a must-visit for a taste of authentic Atlantic City history.
5. John's Boy Pizzeria (Glen Rock)
This storied, family-owned parlor in North Jersey offers a cozy and classic neighborhood pizzeria experience. John's Boy Pizzeria is a beloved local institution known for its fantastic New York-style pies. They serve up perfectly foldable slices with a great crust-to-sauce-to-cheese ratio in a comfortable setting. It's a fantastic place to enjoy a classic slice and other traditional Italian dishes.
New Jersey's pizza scene is a delicious and diverse landscape steeped in history and local pride. From the unique tomato pies of the Trenton area and the legendary thin-crust of Tacconelli's to the classic tavern-style pies at Conte's, the Garden State offers a world-class experience for any pizza lover. Exploring these iconic pizzerias is a must for a true taste of New Jersey.
